The New York Borough That New Yorkers Dismiss — and Why They’re So Wrong

Sharing is caring!

Every New Yorker has made the joke. The forgotten borough. The place people only go to by accident, on a wrong turn toward New Jersey. But dismiss Staten Island too quickly and you miss something the rest of the city has quietly been losing for decades.

The Free Ride That Beats Every Paid Attraction

The Staten Island Ferry runs 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. It carries you across New York Harbor in about 25 minutes. It gives you a front-row view of the Statue of Liberty, Ellis Island, and the lower Manhattan skyline.

And it costs nothing.

Tourists line up and pay $30 or more for observation decks with views of the city. The Staten Island Ferry offers a perspective most of them will never see — from the water itself, at eye level with the harbor — and it’s one of the best free experiences in New York City.

Most locals who ride it daily stop noticing. First-timers never forget it.

A History That Predates Manhattan’s Fame

People forget that Europeans settled Staten Island before they fully settled much of what is now New York City. Dutch settlers arrived in the 1600s, and the island remained largely rural for centuries while Manhattan grew into a financial and cultural center.

That older New York survives in unexpected places. Snug Harbor Cultural Center and Botanical Garden, on the north shore, was once the largest sailors’ home in the United States — a grand Greek Revival complex built in 1833. Today it’s an arts center with botanical gardens, a Chinese Scholar’s Garden, and a culture lab, sitting on 83 acres of land that feels nothing like the rest of New York.

Conference House, at the island’s southern tip, dates to the 1680s. It hosted a failed peace meeting between American and British representatives during the Revolutionary War. It’s one of the oldest stone buildings in New York — and almost nobody outside Staten Island can tell you it exists.

Where New York Still Feels Like Itself

There’s a version of New York that most people see in old photographs but struggle to find in Manhattan or Brooklyn anymore. Quiet residential streets. Brownstones with stoops. Neighborhoods where people know each other’s names.

Staten Island still has it.

The North Shore — places like St. George, Tompkinsville, and New Brighton — has been quietly changing, with restaurants, galleries, and creative communities moving in alongside long-established Italian, Sri Lankan, and West African families. It’s the kind of neighborhood story that rarely makes the tourist guides but defines what makes New York’s hidden gems worth finding.

The island also contains the New York City Greenbelt — 2,800 acres of forests, wetlands, and trails within the city limits. You can walk for hours without seeing a skyscraper.

In a city where every neighborhood seems to have been discovered, developed, and rebranded in the last twenty years, that kind of space feels quietly remarkable.

Enjoying this? Join New York lovers getting stories like this every week. Subscribe free →

The Joke That Got Old

The “forgotten borough” label has stuck for decades. Some of it came from the island’s identity as a community for working-class families — police officers, firefighters, construction workers — who commuted to Manhattan jobs and came home to something more like a suburb.

What the joke misses is that this was always a feature, not a flaw. Staten Island was never trying to compete with Manhattan or Brooklyn. It had its own character: deeply Italian-American in many neighborhoods, proudly working-class, intensely local.

When the rest of New York was transforming into luxury boutiques and $22 cocktails, Staten Island largely stayed Staten Island.

The View That Stays With You

On the return ferry crossing, as the boat turns back toward St. George terminal and Manhattan fills the horizon, something happens. The people on deck — many of them regulars who have made this crossing a thousand times — pause and look.

The skyline at dusk is extraordinary from out there on the water. Old buildings and new towers reflected in the harbor. The Statue of Liberty off to the left. The light changing as the sun drops over New Jersey.

It’s the view of New York that most visitors never get. And it belongs to the borough they spent the least time thinking about.

Staten Island may never shake its reputation as the place people end up by mistake. But that’s part of what protects it. The city’s best-kept secrets rarely announce themselves.

You Might Also Enjoy

• Hidden Gems in NYC: The New York Most Tourists Never See
• The Island Just 800 Yards From Manhattan That Was Off-Limits for 200 Years
• Free Things to Do in NYC: The Best No-Cost Experiences

Plan Your New York Trip

Ready to explore all five boroughs? The Ultimate New York Travel Guide covers neighborhoods, food, museums, and practical tips for every kind of visitor.