The Park Built on 20,000 Graves That Became the Heart of New York

Sharing is caring!

Stand at the center of Washington Square Park on any afternoon and you’ll see musicians, chess players, students, and tourists. What you won’t see — what the city has never advertised — is the 20,000 people buried beneath your feet.

Washington Square Park is New York City’s most beloved public gathering place. It’s also one of its largest graveyards.

A Field of the Forgotten

Before it was a park — before the iconic arch, before the fountain, before any of it — this patch of lower Manhattan was a potter’s field. That was the old term for a burial ground reserved for the poor, the unknown, and the unclaimed.

From 1797 to 1825, the city buried thousands here. Yellow fever victims. The destitute. Enslaved people who died in the city. Anyone without the means or the family to pay for a proper burial.

Estimates put the number at as many as 20,000 people interred in what is now the park. The bodies remain there today. The city has always known this. It hasn’t always broadcast it.

The Tree That Saw Everything First

Before it was even a burial ground, Washington Square had a grimmer chapter. In the late 18th century, a large elm near the northern edge served as a public execution site. Hangings were carried out here openly, as a form of civic spectacle.

New Yorkers called it the Hangman’s Elm.

That tree still stands. Estimated at over 300 years old, it grows in the park’s northwest corner today — one of the oldest living trees in Manhattan, quietly watching everything the park has become.

After the potter’s field closed in 1825, the land became a military parade ground. Cannons were positioned here. Regiments drilled. The city was proud of its orderly, purposeful public square. Then the wealthy arrived.

The Houses That Changed Everything

In the 1830s, New York’s merchant class discovered Washington Square. The north side of the park was lined with red-brick Greek Revival townhouses — elegant, uniform, and unmistakably affluent.

Henry James grew up nearby and later used Washington Square as the title of his most celebrated New York novel. Edith Wharton lived on the block. For a brief, gleaming period, this was the most fashionable address in the city.

Then, as the wealthy moved uptown — to Fifth Avenue, to the East Sixties, to wherever New York’s money always chases itself — something unexpected filled the vacuum. Artists moved in. Students arrived. Bohemia set up camp in the cheap apartments and basement cafes around the square.

The Bohemian Capital of New York

By the early 20th century, Greenwich Village had become something entirely different. Radicals, poets, painters, and thinkers gathered around Washington Square. Emma Goldman gave speeches nearby. Eugene O’Neill drank here. The Provincetown Players staged experimental theater in its orbit.

In the 1950s, the Beat writers came. Jack Kerouac and Allen Ginsberg found their New York in the coffee houses along MacDougal Street, steps from the park’s southern edge.

In the 1960s, a young Bob Dylan played his earliest New York sets in the cafes around the square. If you want to understand how New York became the center of American artistic life, Washington Square is where that story begins.

Enjoying this? Join New York lovers getting stories like this every week. Subscribe free →

The Arch That Was Never Part of the Plan

The arch that dominates Washington Square’s northern entrance wasn’t part of any original design for the park.

In 1889, New York celebrated the centennial of George Washington’s presidential inauguration with a temporary wooden arch built nearby. The city loved it. The celebrated architect Stanford White designed a permanent marble replacement, completed in 1895. It stands 77 feet tall, carved from Tompkins Cove marble — one of the most recognizable structures in the city.

In 1917, a group of bohemian artists broke into the arch and climbed to the top. They declared the Village an independent nation — the Free and Independent Republic of Washington Square — and read a proclamation from the roof. The city ignored them entirely. The story became legend.

What Lies Beneath Has Never Moved

City projects over the decades have repeatedly encountered the remains of the park’s original occupants. Infrastructure repairs. Construction work. Each time, officials navigate the quiet reality that this beloved public space rests on thousands of unmarked graves.

There are no markers for most of those buried here. No memorial for the yellow fever dead, or the enslaved people interred in this ground, or the thousands of paupers placed in the earth with nothing but a pine box.

That’s part of Washington Square’s story too — the parts the city has never put on plaques.

Stand at the fountain on your next visit. Look north at the arch. Listen to the chess players and the musicians and the students arguing about everything and nothing. All of it is happening above the city’s forgotten. That’s New York in one place — the living and the lost, layered on top of each other, inseparable.

You Might Also Enjoy

• The Village Mask-Maker Who Accidentally Gave New York Its Most Beloved Night of the Year
• Why New York Tried to Rename Hell’s Kitchen — and Nobody Listened
• The Downtown Bar Where American Art Stopped Apologizing to Paris

Plan Your New York Trip

Exploring Greenwich Village and beyond? Our guide to New York’s best neighborhoods covers everything from where to stay to what to eat on your first trip to the city.