The New York Restaurant That Invented the Menu, the Steak, and American Fine Dining

Sharing is caring!

In 1827, two Swiss immigrant brothers opened a small pastry shop on William Street in Lower Manhattan. They sold wine and cakes. They had no idea what they were starting. Within a generation, they had changed how America ate — and invented the idea of the modern restaurant.

The Delmonico brothers’ restaurant became a place where you chose what you wanted. Where a printed list of dishes awaited you instead of whatever the cook had made that morning. Where unescorted women were welcome at the best tables. Today that sounds obvious. In 1830, it was extraordinary.

A Radical Piece of Paper

When Delmonico’s first printed a menu, it was unlike anything Americans had experienced.

Taverns and boardinghouses fed people on a fixed schedule. You ate what was served. The price was the same for everyone. There was no choosing, no individual service, no customer in any meaningful sense.

Delmonico’s changed that with a sheet of paper. Eleven types of bread. Nine types of cake. Dozens of dishes, each with its own price. Diners made selections. They were charged for what they ordered.

The idea traveled fast. Within decades, it had become the model for restaurants across the country. That first printed menu at Delmonico’s is one of the reasons Americans think of eating out the way they do today.

The Dishes That Outlived the Kitchen

In 1876, a sea captain named Ben Wenberg arrived at Delmonico’s with a recipe — a rich, creamy lobster preparation made tableside in a chafing dish. Chef Charles Ranhofer refined it and put it on the menu as Lobster à la Wenberg.

Then Wenberg and the restaurant had a falling-out. Ranhofer simply rearranged the letters. Lobster Newburg. The name change stuck, the story survived, and the dish appears on menus across the country to this day.

The Delmonico steak — a boneless cut from the short loin — carries the restaurant’s name because it was popularized here. Ranhofer’s cookbook, published in 1894, ran to nearly 1,200 pages and became the first major American culinary reference. Nothing like it existed before.

Baked Alaska — ice cream encased in a shell of hot toasted meringue — was created in this kitchen for a celebratory dinner. The drama of cold inside and heat outside was exactly the kind of theater Delmonico’s was built for. If you want to understand where American New York food culture came from, this kitchen is a good place to start.

The Table Where Everyone Ate

Charles Dickens ate at Delmonico’s during his American tours and declared it the only restaurant in the country worthy of serious comparison to the best in Europe. Mark Twain was a regular. Oscar Wilde dined there during his 1882 lecture tour.

Diamond Jim Brady — the financier famous for eating with operatic excess — had his corner of the dining room. He reportedly arrived for dinner in the early evening and was still at the table well past midnight, ordering one course after another.

Abraham Lincoln dined at Delmonico’s. So did generals, novelists, and railroad barons whose names filled the newspapers of the day. If you were notable in New York between 1830 and 1920, you almost certainly had a table here.

Enjoying this? Join New York lovers getting stories like this every week. Subscribe free →

A Table Reserved for Women

In 19th-century New York, a woman who entered a restaurant without a male escort was considered improper at best, scandalous at worst. Hotels kept separate “ladies’ dining rooms” — smaller, plainer, set apart from the main floor where men conducted business over lunch.

Delmonico’s opened its main dining room to women dining without escorts. At good tables. In full view of everyone else.

This was not the norm. Lillian Russell — the actress who was perhaps the most recognized woman in America at the time — ate at Delmonico’s publicly, without apology. Newspapers noted it. Society noticed. The restaurant was quietly changing not just what New Yorkers ate, but who got to eat where.

What Prohibition Ended

Delmonico’s survived the Civil War, financial panics, and five separate moves northward as Manhattan grew. Each time the wealthy neighborhoods shifted uptown, the restaurant followed — from William Street to Broad Street, to 14th, to 26th, eventually to Fifth Avenue.

Prohibition did not care about any of that. The Volstead Act arrived in 1920. Wine pairings, cognac reductions, champagne suppers — all of it gone. A restaurant that had built its identity on the European tradition of wine with food suddenly had no wine to serve.

The last Delmonico’s closed in 1923, after 96 years of continuous operation. It wasn’t fire or competition that ended it. It was a federal law that misunderstood what a restaurant was.

New York has always had its own relationship with the places where it eats — from coin-operated automats to corner bodegas. Delmonico’s was where that relationship began. The idea that food was worth choosing, worth paying attention to, worth sitting down for.

A restaurant called Delmonico’s operates today at 56 Beaver Street — inside a beautiful 1891 building, a few blocks from the original William Street address. The Lobster Newburg is still on the menu.

Whether you stop in for a meal or just walk past that stone facade in the Financial District, you’re standing near the place where American dining was invented. Not in Paris. Not in London. In Lower Manhattan, by two brothers who thought their customers deserved something to choose from.

You Might Also Enjoy

• The New York Cafeteria Where You Fed Coins Into the Wall — and Nothing Has Replaced It
• Why New Yorkers Have Been Fighting Over Hot Dog Carts for 150 Years
• The Immigrant Pastry That Fed New York for Over a Century — and Still Does

Plan Your New York Trip

Ready to explore the city that invented so much of what we think of as American culture? Our New York food guide covers the essential dishes and neighborhoods every visitor should know — from the Financial District to the outer boroughs.