Best Pizza in New York City: A Guide to the City’s Greatest Pizzerias (2026)

Sharing is caring!

The best pizza in New York City is a subject New Yorkers treat with genuine seriousness. Everyone has an opinion, and almost nobody agrees. What they do agree on is this: New York pizza stands apart from everything else on earth. If you visit the city without eating at least one seriously good slice, you have missed something essential. This guide takes you to the pizzerias worth crossing a borough for — from coal-fired Brooklyn institutions to Manhattan counter joints that have fed the city for nearly a century.

What Makes New York Pizza Different?

New York pizza has a character that comes from several things working together. The dough stretches thin. The slices are wide and foldable. The crust stays crisp outside while remaining chewy within. Much of this character comes from the city’s water — New York’s tap water has a mineral composition that affects how dough behaves. Some pizzerias have shipped water to other cities to test the theory.

The coal-fired and wood-fired ovens used by the oldest establishments reach temperatures that domestic ovens cannot match. They produce a char and smokiness that gas-fired alternatives simply cannot replicate. You can taste the difference instantly.

Two main styles dominate the city. The classic New York slice is large, foldable, and sold by the piece at counter joints across every borough. The Neapolitan pie is smaller, round, and blistered with a leopard-spot char from a very hot wood oven. Both are worth your time. The decision depends on your mood and how much time you have.

If you want to understand where pizza fits in New York’s broader food culture, our complete guide to eating in New York City covers everything from bagels and pastrami to dishes by neighbourhood and the best markets in town.

Brooklyn: The Heart of New York Pizza

Brooklyn built New York’s pizza reputation, and it remains the borough where the best slices and pies tend to live. These are the places that draw devoted visitors from across the city — and, in some cases, from across the world.

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria, DUMBO

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria sits in DUMBO beneath the shadow of the Manhattan Bridge, and it draws queues even on weekday mornings. The coal-fired brick oven produces a crust with a smokiness that gas-fired alternatives cannot replicate. Grimaldi’s sells whole pies only — no slices — so go hungry. Order the Margherita: fresh mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, fresh basil, and that characteristic char from decades of continuous use. It is as good as this style of pizza gets anywhere in the world.

DUMBO makes a brilliant lunchtime destination. The Manhattan Bridge frames Washington Street in one of the city’s most photographed views. The neighbourhood has galleries, coffee shops, and excellent waterfront views of lower Manhattan. Our guide to things to do in DUMBO covers the full neighbourhood.

Lucali, Carroll Gardens

Critics and chefs regularly name Lucali among the best restaurants in New York City — not just the best pizzerias. Mark Iacono opened it in Carroll Gardens in 2006 in a small space that holds around thirty people. The wood-fired pies come topped with ingredients that shift with the season. There is no phone booking. You add your name to a list and wait, sometimes for two hours. People bring their own wine. The atmosphere is warm and unhurried. The pizza itself repays every minute of that wait many times over.

Di Fara Pizza, Midwood

Di Fara Pizza opened on Avenue J in Midwood in 1964. Decades of attention have not dimmed its reputation. Domenico DeMarco built this place into a New York institution through obsessive attention to ingredients: fresh mozzarella cut to order, San Marzano tomatoes from Italy, basil snipped from a fresh bunch. His family carries that tradition on today. Di Fara sits far from the tourist belt — you take the Q train deep into Brooklyn — but the pilgrimage is part of the experience, and the pizza rewards it completely.

Roberta’s, Bushwick

Roberta’s opened in Bushwick in 2008 and changed the conversation around New York pizza. The wood-fired Neapolitan pies come with inventive toppings — combinations like caciocavallo with chilli, or seasonal vegetables from the on-site rooftop garden — alongside impeccably simple classics. The outdoor area with bar seating makes it a natural summer destination. Bushwick sits alongside Williamsburg, and the two make an excellent afternoon combined. Our guide to Williamsburg is a useful starting point for planning a day in east Brooklyn.

Manhattan: Legends That Have Stood for Decades

Manhattan’s finest pizza joints are institutions. Many have operated from the same location for generations, following the same methods, serving the same loyal customers. The city has not improved on what they do, because improvement is not necessary.

Joe’s Pizza, Greenwich Village

If you want one slice that captures everything New York pizza means, buy a plain slice from Joe’s Pizza on Carmine Street. Joe Pozzuoli opened this counter in Greenwich Village in 1975. It has never tried to be anything other than what it is: a brilliantly made slice, crisp and foldable, available from early afternoon until late at night. It costs a few dollars. You fold it and eat it standing up. It is perfect. Go once and you will find yourself going back every time you pass through the neighbourhood. Our Greenwich Village guide covers everything else the area has to offer.

John’s of Bleecker Street, West Village

John’s of Bleecker Street has operated from the same West Village address since 1929. The coal-fired brick oven produces pies with a charred base and a chewy, flavourful crust. John’s sells full pies only — no slices — and the dining room fills quickly at dinner. The space has a genuinely old New York atmosphere: booths worn smooth by decades of use, high brick walls, and a noise level that confirms the room is always busy. A meal here feels less like a restaurant visit and more like a piece of the city’s actual history.

Patsy’s Pizzeria, East Harlem

Patsy’s Pizzeria in East Harlem is the oldest pizzeria in New York still operating from its original location. Pasquale “Patsy” Lancieri opened it in 1933, and the coal-fired oven has burned ever since. The thin-crust pies are lighter and crispier than many Brooklyn rivals. A clean, delicate char defines the flavour. East Harlem rewards exploration: the Italian-American heritage, the local street life, and the proximity to Central Park make it a satisfying half-day. Our guide to Harlem shows what else is nearby.

Prince Street Pizza, NoLIta

Prince Street Pizza in NoLIta has built its reputation on the spicy spring square: a thick, airy Sicilian-style slice topped with crispy pepperoni that cups and crisps in the oven. The queue snakes down Prince Street at lunchtime, which tells you everything. Sicilian pizza is a different experience from the classic New York slice. It is thicker, chewier, and more filling. If you have only eaten round pies, a stop here gives you a genuine sense of how diverse New York’s pizza culture actually is.

Tips for Ordering Pizza in New York City

New York pizza comes with its own unwritten rules. Follow them and you will fit right in.

• Fold the slice lengthwise. New York slices design themselves around the fold. It controls dripping, keeps the tip from drooping, and marks you as someone who has done this before.
• Eat standing up. Most slice joints have no seating, or very little. Standing at a counter with a slice in one hand and a soda in the other is the authentic experience.
• Go in the early afternoon. The pizza is fresh, the oven runs hot, and the lunchtime queues have cleared. Slices that have sat under a heat lamp since 11am are a diminished version of the real thing.
• Walk away from Times Square. The pizza within a block or two of Times Square serves volume, not quality. Walk four or five blocks in any direction and the quality improves significantly.
• Carry cash. Several of the best and oldest joints prefer or require cash. Some do not accept cards at all.
• Expect a queue at the great places. Lucali often has a two-hour wait. Di Fara draws crowds every afternoon. A long queue usually means you are in the right place.
• Ask a local. New Yorkers love their pizza and love talking about it. Ask which pizzeria they prefer and you will get a strong opinion delivered with complete conviction.

Queens: A Borough Worth Adding to Your Pizza Route

Queens does not dominate pizza conversation the way Brooklyn does, but it deserves more attention. The borough has a dense concentration of outstanding family-run pizzerias operating without the fanfare of their Manhattan or Brooklyn counterparts. Astoria has several excellent neighbourhood joints where you eat very well for very little money, surrounded by locals rather than tourists.

If you plan to spend time in the borough, our guide to Astoria covers the neighbourhood in full, including its excellent food scene along Steinway Street and 30th Avenue.

Planning Your New York Pizza Day

The best approach is to build pizza into your days rather than treating it as a separate activity. Stay in DUMBO for lunch and work in Grimaldi’s naturally. Walk through Greenwich Village in the evening and stop at Joe’s on the way. Combine a visit to East Harlem with a pie at Patsy’s.

New York’s best pizza joints sit inside neighbourhoods worth knowing. Visiting them is a way of knowing those neighbourhoods better. If you want help structuring your days across the city, our three-day New York City itinerary gives you a practical framework that works for first-time visitors and returning ones alike.

Frequently Asked Questions About New York City Pizza

What is the best pizza in New York City for first-time visitors?

Joe’s Pizza on Carmine Street in Greenwich Village is the ideal starting point. It serves a classic New York slice that perfectly represents the style, costs very little, and requires no booking or long wait. From there, Grimaldi’s in DUMBO gives you the coal-fired pie experience in a neighbourhood worth visiting for its own sake.

Is there a difference between Brooklyn pizza and Manhattan pizza?

Brooklyn’s most celebrated pizzerias tend to use coal-fired or wood-fired brick ovens, which produce a more charred and smoky crust at very high temperatures. Many Manhattan spots follow the same approach. The distinction matters less than the oven type and the tradition of each individual place. Both boroughs have outstanding options.

Do I need to book a table at New York City’s best pizzerias?

Most classic New York slice joints require no booking at all — you walk in, order at the counter, and eat standing up. For sit-down places like Lucali and John’s of Bleecker Street, expect a wait rather than a reservation system. Lucali operates a walk-in waiting list only. Arriving early in the evening or at lunchtime reduces your wait significantly.

What is the best neighbourhood in New York City for pizza?

Brooklyn offers the greatest concentration of celebrated pizzerias, particularly in DUMBO, Carroll Gardens, and Bushwick. In Manhattan, Greenwich Village and the West Village have the strongest cluster of long-established institutions. If you want one neighbourhood that combines great pizza with a brilliant setting, DUMBO — with Grimaldi’s steps from the waterfront and the Brooklyn Bridge in view — is hard to beat.