The Three Women Who Founded MoMA in a Manhattan Office — and Changed Art Forever

Sharing is caring!

Nine days after the stock market crashed in 1929, three women sat down in a Manhattan office and agreed to do something everyone told them was impossible. They were going to build a museum for art that most of America didn’t understand — and didn’t want to.

The City That Said No

The Metropolitan Museum of Art had already turned them down. The established art world wasn’t interested. Modern art — the kind made by Cézanne, Picasso, and van Gogh — was considered foreign, unintelligible, and not suitable for American institutions.

But Abby Aldrich Rockefeller, Mary Quinn Sullivan, and Lillie P. Bliss weren’t asking for permission.

They were already collecting. They already had a vision. And on November 7, 1929, they opened the Museum of Modern Art on the twelfth floor of an office building on Fifth Avenue.

Three Women, One Impossible Idea

Abby Aldrich Rockefeller was the most formidable of the three. Her husband, John D. Rockefeller Jr., thought modern art was “unintelligible.” She collected it anyway — quietly, persistently, and with complete conviction.

Lillie P. Bliss was a pianist and socialite who had spent years building one of the finest private collections of modern art in America. She would eventually leave her entire collection to MoMA in her will — 181 paintings and works on paper that became the museum’s permanent foundation.

Mary Quinn Sullivan was a painter and art teacher who understood what ordinary people needed to feel when they stood in front of a painting. She knew collectors, she could work a room, and she believed deeply that great art should not live behind velvet ropes.

Together, they hired a 27-year-old director named Alfred H. Barr Jr. and told him to build something New York had never seen before.

A Museum Unlike Anything That Came Before It

Every major museum in New York in 1929 looked like a temple. Marble floors. Greek columns. Old masters behind velvet ropes and dim lighting that discouraged lingering.

MoMA’s first exhibition was deliberately different. Barr hung Cézanne, Gauguin, Seurat, and van Gogh on plain white walls with bright, honest lighting. The labels were short. The layout was open. The message was unmistakable: this art is for you.

Seven thousand people came in the first week. The Met had dismissed these very artists for decades. A twelfth-floor office on Fifth Avenue drew a crowd that would make the city’s oldest institution take notice.

Enjoying this? Join New York lovers getting stories like this every week. Subscribe free →

The Crash That Changed Nothing

It is one of history’s stranger coincidences. MoMA opened just nine days after Black Tuesday — the moment the stock market collapsed and the Great Depression began.

In a city gripped by financial panic, three women had just committed to building a cultural institution from nothing. Most people assumed it would close within months.

It didn’t. It grew. The Depression gave New York’s cultural scene an unexpected intensity. People wanted beauty. They wanted meaning. They wanted somewhere to go that felt like the future rather than the collapse of the present. MoMA gave them all of it.

The Legacy They Built

Lillie P. Bliss died in 1931, just two years after the museum opened. She left her entire collection to MoMA on one condition: that the museum raise its own endowment first. It did — and the Bliss bequest became the cornerstone of MoMA’s permanent collection.

Abby Rockefeller donated more than 2,000 works over her lifetime and eventually convinced her son Nelson Rockefeller to join the board. The Rockefeller name became synonymous with MoMA’s ambitions.

The museum moved to its permanent home on West 53rd Street in 1939. Today it holds more than 200,000 works — from Picasso’s Les Demoiselles d’Avignon to Warhol’s soup cans to a 1909 airplane suspended from the ceiling of its design galleries.

Why It Still Matters

New York has always been a city that fights over its art — the mural artists who were scrubbed from its walls learned that lesson the hard way. What made MoMA’s founders different was that they didn’t wait for the fight to be over before they started building.

They didn’t wait for permission. They didn’t wait for the economy to recover. They didn’t wait for the art world to catch up with them.

They rented a twelfth-floor office, hung some paintings on the wall, and let the city decide. Seven thousand people showed up in a week.

That is — as New Yorkers would say — as New York as it gets.

You Might Also Enjoy

• Why Every American Writer in the 1950s Needed to Live in Greenwich Village — another corner of New York where creative revolution was born
• The Night New York’s Greatest Outdoor Art Museum Was Whitewashed — and What It Cost — the story of the city’s most controversial public art battle

Plan Your New York Trip

Ready to experience New York’s cultural riches firsthand? Explore the best free things to do in New York City — including some of the city’s greatest museums and galleries.