The Mural Rockefeller Paid For, Had Plastered Over, and Smashed in the Dead of Night

Sharing is caring!

In February 1934, workers arrived at 30 Rockefeller Plaza late at night. They carried hammers and chisels. Their job was to destroy one of the most stunning murals in American history — paid for by the richest family in the country, painted by the most celebrated artist in the Western Hemisphere, and considered too dangerous to be seen.

A Commission Nobody Expected

In 1932, John D. Rockefeller Jr. was building the most ambitious architectural project in New York’s history. Rockefeller Center would rise as a city within a city — seventeen towers in the heart of Midtown, anchored by 30 Rockefeller Plaza.

He wanted the lobby to say something about the future of human civilization. So he hired Diego Rivera to paint it.

Rivera was the most celebrated muralist alive. His work covered the walls of Mexico City, Detroit, and San Francisco. He was also a committed Communist, openly sympathetic to the Soviet Union. Rockefeller — one of capitalism’s most powerful symbols — hired him anyway.

There was a remarkable twist in that decision. Rockefeller’s wife, Abby Aldrich Rockefeller, was one of the three women who had founded the Museum of Modern Art just three years earlier. She admired Rivera’s work deeply. In 1931, MoMA had given Rivera one of the most celebrated solo exhibitions in the young museum’s history. The Rockefeller family, in other words, had more than one complicated relationship with this particular artist.

The Detail That Changed Everything

Rivera’s approved sketch showed a worker at a crossroads between capitalism and socialism — a figure surrounded by the machinery of the modern age, reaching toward a future of peace and progress. Rockefeller signed off on it.

Then Rivera started painting the final version. And he added something he hadn’t shown in the sketches.

Among the marching figures on the left side of the composition, Rivera painted a portrait. Clear and unmistakable: Vladimir Lenin, leader of the Russian Revolution, clasping hands with workers of different races.

Rockefeller wrote Rivera a polite letter. He asked that Lenin’s face be replaced with an anonymous worker’s face. Rivera replied just as politely. He would not make the change, he said — but he’d be happy to balance the composition by adding a portrait of Abraham Lincoln on the other side.

The offer was declined.

Enjoying this? Join New York lovers getting stories like this every week. Subscribe free →

Paid in Full, Escorted Out

On May 9, 1933, Rockefeller Center staff arrived at Rivera’s scaffolding. He was still working. A staffer handed him an envelope containing a check for his full fee — $21,000. Then he was escorted from the building.

The mural was immediately covered with a plain brown paper curtain. Officially, the project was on pause. Unofficially, it was over.

Rivera appealed to the art world. He asked that the unfinished fresco be donated to a museum rather than destroyed. The Museum of Modern Art, co-founded by Rockefeller’s own wife, declined to get involved. Rivera’s supporters organized protests. Newspapers ran editorials. None of it changed anything.

For nine months, the mural sat hidden behind its brown paper curtain on the lobby wall. Then came February 1934.

The Night the Hammers Came

Workers arrived after midnight. They didn’t try to strip the plaster carefully — that would have taken too long and drawn attention. Instead, they chipped it away piece by piece, letting the fragments fall to the lobby floor below.

By morning, the wall was bare. The lobby was eventually repainted with a quietly inoffensive mural by Spanish artist José Maria Sert — a piece so unremarkable that most visitors today don’t give it a second glance.

Rivera learned about the destruction from a newspaper report.

He was furious. A fresco is painted directly into wet plaster, fused permanently with the wall. It cannot be rolled up, crated, or moved. Destroying the plaster meant destroying the painting entirely. There was nothing left to save, nothing to export, nothing to preserve.

Rivera’s Quiet Revenge

Rivera went home to Mexico. Within months, he had recreated the entire composition from memory on the walls of the Palace of Fine Arts in Mexico City. He titled it Man, Controller of the Universe.

Lenin is still there. Rivera also expanded the composition significantly — adding more workers, more machines, more cosmic imagery than the original had contained.

And if you look at the crowd on the right side of the painting — the side representing capitalism and excess — you’ll find a face Rivera added that wasn’t in the original New York version. Standing among the partygoers, surrounded by champagne glasses and stock tickers, is John D. Rockefeller Jr. himself.

What the Lobby Holds Now

The artists who came after Rivera — the Abstract Expressionists who remade American painting in the postwar decades — understood the lesson. New York could be the world capital of art. But the city had its own complicated relationship with what artists were permitted to say.

Rockefeller Center is still one of the most visited places in New York. The lobby at 30 Rock still has its mural, still holds its crowds of tourists and office workers. Most people walk through without looking up.

Rivera’s mural is gone — destroyed down to dust on a February night ninety years ago. But somehow it remains one of the most vivid things that ever happened in that building. New York has always been a city where ambition and argument live side by side. The story of the mural is just one version of that argument playing out at the highest possible stakes.

You Might Also Enjoy

• The Three Women Who Founded MoMA in a Manhattan Office and Changed Art Forever
• The New York Hotel That Let Artists Pay Rent with Paintings
• The Downtown Bar Where American Art Stopped Apologizing to Paris

Plan Your New York Trip

Ready to walk the streets where these stories happened? Our three-day New York itinerary takes you through Midtown, the art world neighborhoods of Chelsea and SoHo, and everything in between.