The Brooklyn Neighborhood That New Yorkers Abandoned — Then the Whole World Came Running

Sharing is caring!

There is a block in Brooklyn that tourists now photograph obsessively, that coffee connoisseurs argue over, that real estate agents use to justify prices that once seemed impossible. But forty years ago, the people who lived there were leaving as fast as they could.

Williamsburg did not transform quietly. It lurched, stumbled, reinvented itself, and then watched the world arrive — often to the frustration of everyone who had been there first.

When Williamsburg Ran on Sugar and Sweat

Before Bedford Avenue meant artisanal everything, it meant work. Hard, unglamorous, industrial work.

The Domino Sugar refinery opened on the Williamsburg waterfront in 1856. At its peak, it processed roughly half of all the sugar consumed in the United States. The smell of hot sugar hung over the neighborhood constantly. Workers — mostly immigrants — lived in tight rows of tenements within walking distance of the factory.

Breweries, glassworks, and chemical plants filled in the gaps. Williamsburg was one of the most productive industrial zones in America. It was also, by most accounts, exhausting to live in.

The Families Who Made It Home Anyway

Through the early twentieth century, Williamsburg became one of the great immigrant communities of New York. Jewish families from Eastern Europe settled here in enormous numbers, drawn by cheap rents and the promise of factory work.

Italians, Poles, and Puerto Rican families followed in subsequent decades, each wave reshaping the neighborhood’s rhythms. Markets, synagogues, social clubs, and corner stores built the infrastructure of community out of necessity.

By the 1950s, Williamsburg was dense and alive. It was also beginning to fray. Factories were closing. Jobs were disappearing. The middle class was moving to the suburbs, following highways out of the city.

The Artists Who Moved In When Everyone Else Moved Out

By the 1970s and 1980s, Williamsburg had become somewhere people warned each other about. Buildings stood empty. Blocks felt hollow. The waterfront, without its industrial tenants, was just a stretch of crumbling concrete facing Manhattan.

That was precisely why artists started arriving.

Rents were almost nothing. Warehouse spaces could be converted into enormous studios for next to no money. Painters, musicians, and writers who had been priced out of Manhattan’s SoHo and East Village discovered that the L train could drop them in a neighborhood that nobody else wanted — yet.

Enjoying this? Join New York lovers getting stories like this every week. Subscribe free →

Through the late 1980s and into the 1990s, a quiet creative scene took root. Galleries opened in former loading docks. Bands played in improvised venues. The neighborhood remained rough, unpolished, and entirely uncelebrated — which was exactly the point.

How Bedford Avenue Became the Most Referenced Block in Brooklyn

Sometime in the late 1990s, something shifted. The artists brought coffee shops. The coffee shops brought the curious. The curious brought money — slowly at first, then all at once.

By the mid-2000s, Williamsburg had become shorthand for a particular kind of urban cool. Bedford Avenue was written about in magazines across the country. Flannel, fixed-gear bicycles, and record stores became part of a cultural shorthand that reached far beyond New York.

The neighborhood that had once been abandoned was now the subject of thinkpieces. Longtime residents — including Hasidic Jewish and Latino communities who had held on through the lean decades — found themselves in a neighborhood that felt increasingly unrecognizable.

The brownstones of surrounding Brooklyn had survived decades of neglect; now they were being converted and sold at prices that seemed fictional compared to what their owners had paid.

The Day the L Train Changed Everything — Again

In 2016, the MTA announced that the L train tunnel under the East River would need to close for repairs — an extended shutdown that would cut Williamsburg off from Manhattan entirely. The neighborhood that had built its identity around easy access to the city suddenly faced an existential question.

Businesses braced for collapse. Residents made contingency plans. Real estate analysts predicted a mass exodus. It became one of the most-discussed urban planning events in New York’s recent history.

Then, in 2019, the plan was reversed. The tunnel would be repaired without a full shutdown, using a different technique. The crisis that never quite arrived became its own chapter in the ongoing story of Brooklyn’s resilience.

What Williamsburg Is Now — and What It’s Still Becoming

The Domino Sugar factory site is now a park. On summer evenings, people stretch out on the grass where workers once shoveled raw cane. The factory’s famous sign still stands — a deliberate preservation of the neighborhood’s industrial past in the middle of its residential present.

Luxury towers have risen along the waterfront. Rooftop bars overlook the Manhattan skyline. Rents that once attracted artists now attract finance workers. The creative exodus that began in SoHo in the 1980s has played out again, with Williamsburg as both destination and departure point.

Yet the neighborhood has not been entirely smoothed away. Pockets of the original community remain. The sounds and smells of different cultures still layer over each other on certain blocks. The L train still carries an improbable mix of people who have no obvious reason to be neighbors.

Williamsburg’s story is New York’s story: a relentless cycling of arrival, departure, and reinvention. Nobody owns it permanently. Everyone who lives there is, in some sense, temporary.

Which might be the most New York thing about it at all.

You Might Also Enjoy

• Brooklyn in 48 Hours: An Insider’s Guide — the essential stops across the borough
• The Brooklyn Brownstone Was Almost Bulldozed. Then New Yorkers Started Fighting Back.
• The Day Brooklyn Held a Funeral — and Why the Borough Still Won’t Let Go

Plan Your New York Trip

Ready to explore Brooklyn for yourself? Our New York Food Guide covers the essential eats across the borough — from the waterfront to the backstreets.